mepeace.org

Michael Weis

Fayyad: Jews can be equal citizens of Palestine (Good, but ...)

Palestinian Prime Minister Salam Fayyad on Saturday said that Jews would enjoy freedom and full civil rights in a future Palestinian state, according to a report in the Aspen Daily News. (Link)

This is a good statement to promoting trust and acceptance, and further turning the wheels of peace. Fayyad should be applauded, but many Israelis and Jews just don't believe him.

There are many reasons we don't believe him: PA treatment of minorities(Christians, gays, women etc.), lack of evidence of Palestinian support for this statement, we don't know how much support Fayyad has among Palestinians, fighting among rival Palestinian factions, and the election of Hamas.

Rather than go into the details, I have several questions.

1. How much support among Palestinians is there for Fayyad's statement? And for Fayyad as a politician?

2. To Palestinians: What kind of state do you want your future state to be? I know it seems a bit early to discuss this but this is actually important. Zionist have written much about what kind of state or homeland they wish to accomplish many decades before the establishment of Israel. If what you say sounds good, others would support it. Nationalism can unite a people for a goal larger than the the tasks a state has such as running a bureaucracy, such as creating technology (think JFK), improving civil and political rights, or helping people around the world.

3. What problems do you see in the Palestinian Authority which outsiders can help improve?

4. How can we engage elements that treat minorities poorly such as Hamas and other elements in the PA to promote Fayyad's statement?

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Actually, many Palestinian intellectuals have mentioned this. It was also mentioned when Arafat was alive. Christians are generally treated well in Jerusalem and Bethlehem by other Palestinians. Gays are another issue. Christians are treated well, gays are not.
Basically, they hide that they are gay. However, you don't hear about people hunting down gays like you were hearing about in Iraq.

I want a parliamentary system with a prime minister and a president who has some limited powers. There could be some religious influence, but there has to be freedom to choose your religion or change it if you are going to have Jews and Christians in the state and secular Palestinians who want to live in Palestine in comfort. At least, the municipalities should have some autonomy. It shouldn't be overly federal and oppressive.

Reply to This

RSS

Search mepeace.org

Translate on mepeace.org

Photos

Loading…

Growing on mepeace.org

3703 Peacemakers
169 Groups
2060 Discussions
1358 Blog posts
5704 Photos
640 Videos
846 Songs

Latest Activity

Neri Bar-On replied to the discussion 'Gaza today'
32 minutes ago
Oliver Haack joined a group
This is a work in progress group that is a peace for Palestine group, to help build a strong Palestinian camp internationally. The Israelis have Gush Shalom. We need to network with them and other groups. We have to be another voice.
2 hours ago
2 hours ago
3 hours ago
enjoy your time. see you some other time then.
3 hours ago
Benny Faibish added a blog post
למחנה קיץ בן שבוע ימים העוסק בשלום ופתרון סכסוכים בין לאומיים דרושים צעירים הרוצים לקחת חלק בחוויה ייחודית ומעמיקה. המחנה יערך בתחילת יולי בפארק שעשועים בגרמניה, ומשתתפים בו צעירים מכמה אזורים בעולם; מידע נוסף ניתן בטפסים המצורפים. דרישות:גיל 19-…
4 hours ago
Benny Faibish is now friends with Neri Bar-On and Oliver Haack
4 hours ago
Benny Faibish added a discussion
למחנה קיץ בן שבוע ימים העוסק בשלום ופתרון סכסוכים בין לאומיים דרושים צעירים הרוצים לקחת חלק בחוויה ייחודית ומעמיקה.המחנה יערך בתחילת יולי בפארק שעשועים בגרמניה, ומשתתפים בו צעירים מכמה אזורים בעולם; מידע נוסף ניתן בטפסים.  דרישות:- גיל 19-24- שליטה…
4 hours ago
Neri Bar-On added a discussion
source: http://alwasattoday.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=6127:-q-q-&catid=62:2009-07-28-09-09-03  محمود درويش " هوية قيد التاليف والتكوين وانسان يشربه الظل"/ نافذ الرفاعي  الكاتب نافذ الرفاعي  الثلاثاء, 09 مارس 2010 12:28 اع…
5 hours ago
America got slapped in the face, kaman.
5 hours ago
Tanya Kasim replied to the discussion 'Peace'
Hi, David You're welcome for the compliment on your poem and to the link. It's a funny thing about the problems and answers to it in that neither side likes to admit it's wrong. I agree with you that what continues to go on is criminal and unjust a…
5 hours ago
Ohad Bracha added a discussion
And  the majority of Israelis and Israel supporters really exited about it :) It feels good for so many reasons and a much much needed reaction. (its not much of a discussion just felt the need to share my feelings and my hopes from a combination of…
8 hours ago
see david I did not even know you age. would be nice if you put a picture and tell a little about your self . I think the communication would be much nicer
8 hours ago
Sarah Pesto and suleiman abuali are now friends
8 hours ago
I read your post, and then I google “Marda Permaculture Farms”it sounds like a very interesting group. I have a few suggestions for this noble mission of yours. From my experiences and knowledge old geezers like my self have very little to no unders…
9 hours ago
No Irit,,,i will not be there,,,i am guiding a trip to Tibrya and Hamat Gader,,,so i will be out of jerusalem all friday,,,maybe i will pass by in saturday so say hiii to all
10 hours ago
David Crier replied to the discussion 'Peace'
Hello Tanya Thank-you for the compliment on the poem “Peace” and the link to “Columbia Middle East Research Center in Jordan”. Did not see any program on the Palestinian/Israel Crisis and possible roads to peace. I would like to see more on done on…
11 hours ago
Tracy Wallach joined a group
IPCRI is a joint Israeli-Palestinian public policy think tank and do-tank located in Jerusalem. IPCRI has three departments: SAU - Strategic Affairs Unit PED - Peace Education Department W&E - Water & Environment
12 hours ago
We are organizing a conference for Arab and Jewish Diaspora communities in the US. One of the goals of the conference is to examine the influence members of Jewish and Arab Diaspora communities have on both peacemaking and war making and how their p…
12 hours ago
Tracy Wallach joined a group
This is where American Friends of mepeace.org can meet and get to know each other!
12 hours ago

Groups

Badge

Loading…

© 2010   Created by Eyal Raviv

Feedback | Report an Issue  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy  |  Terms of Service

Sign in to chat!